In bird photography there is such a thing as over processing mistakes and the mistake I see most often is adding way too much saturation. So much so that the birds don’t look like they do in real life and sometimes to the point of looking like cartoon caricatures rather than a flesh, blood and feathered bird.
Some people do this to add “pop” to their images and on line, especially on Facebook, those images with “pop” get lots of likes and comments from people who might not know what those birds actually look like in real life.
A few times this past week I have seen photos posted to Facebook groups about birds and bird photography that made my eyes want to close because they were so over processed. One was a Great Egret that had a shadow on the dorsal side of the wings that turned so blue with over processing that that photographer called it a Blue (not sure if they meant Great Blue Heron or Little Blue Heron). Why would that bother me? Because Great Egrets are white and are never blue and the birder and bird photographer in me wanted to scream.
I’ve seen Great Blue Heron images posted where the plumage is a bright royal blue. Great Blue Herons, despite having “blue” in their name are far more gray than blue and they are never, ever bright royal blue.
I’ve posted a side by side comparison of a Reddish Egret portrait, on the left side is the image processed with only a touch of sharpening, zero added saturation. On the right side I added lots of saturation. The left side may “pop” because it is more colorful but in reality Reddish Egrets do not look like that. At all. And the colors in the background wouldn’t either.
This is what they look like. This Reddish Egret is in breeding plumage and their facial features are a bit more colorful at that time. Their lores and bills are more vibrant in breeding plumage but they are not as bright as the over saturated comparison above.
I also wanted to add a side by side comparison of a basically black and white bird so I picked this juvenile Eastern Kingbird. On the left there is zero added saturation and on the right too much saturation. Adding saturation generally doesn’t affect blacks and whites in images but as you can see it did affect the greens and tans of the vegetation behind the kingbird.
Now those background colors aren’t too far from what they looked like straight out of the camera but I truthfully prefer this version that isn’t over saturated.
Some people also add too much contrast along with too much saturation in post processing and that can also make the images “pop” but those images generally don’t look realistic either.
When I process my images I do so with a light hand, I have seen too many images where the saturation and contrast levels were terribly overdone and the birds end up looking like cartoon caricatures because the colors are unreal. I prefer to leave my images as close as possible to what they looked like when created, using only minimal contrast, saturation or levels adjustments along with sharpening for web presentation.
If the person is going for artistic appeal by using filter and textures and adding lots of color & saturation that is completely different, that is photo art not bird photography.
Also, some people may select the “Vivid” color setting in their camera which results in super highly saturated images but they don’t necessarily look like what the bird did at the time the image was taken. I would suggest never using that “vivid” color setting for birds, or wildlife for that matter because the resulting images will not look natural.
I know I have ranted a bit but honestly I have been seriously contemplating leaving some of the Birder and Bird Photography groups on Facebook where you are not allowed to “critique” the images. Just this week I saw someone offer help to another photographer by critiquing another photographer’s image in one of those groups and they got slammed for the critique by several members and then they left the group.
Their advice to the other person on their image was spot on in my opinion.
My advice is to go easy on adding saturation in bird photography to avoid over processing mistakes.
Life is good.